*Authentic Dogs is reader-supported. We may earn commissions if you buy through our links.
Canines are popular not just as companions, but also as guard and security watchdogs. Usually, if protection is at stake, the breed that will come to mind is either Rottweiler or Pitbull. These two doggos are known for their courage and defensive nature.
As depicted in the movies, Rottweilers are the enemies during the ‘90s era while Pitbulls are the villains of today. But if we’re going to talk about their temperament and personality as family and security dogs, the points are polarizing.
Let’s start with the Pitbull first. Aggression is typical for this breed which can be worsened due to lack of companionship. They were bred as fighting dogs which explains why their innate aggression can get best out of their potential to be friendly family dogs. Pitbull vs. Rottweiler, the former has the edge at this point.
Even if they are domesticated alongside cats, there’s no guarantee that they won’t be in attack mode if other pets test their patience. They rarely engage in trouble unless there’s a reason. But if you don’t socialize them and you fail to keep them unaccompanied, they will start to be neurotic and even more dangerous.
As for Rottweilers, they are bred to be herding dogs. Compared to Pitbulls, they are less aggressive and can be friendly to strangers if need be. But due to the unstable bloodlines of this breed, some Rotties may turn out to be more aggressive or stubborn. They usually inherit the temperament of their parents so make sure that you perform some research before buying a specific Rottie.
Both of these doggos would chew incessantly if not kept occupied. They also have to be engaged in regular physical activities, much so for Rottweilers.
Rottweiler vs. Pitbull: Personality
Pitbulls are surrounded by stereotypes due to the abuse they faced from underground dog fighting rings. Sure thing, they can be killer guard dogs, but their personality can be tamed to become friendly and loveable. If they are raised with proper care and affection, Pitbulls can be total sweethearts. But still, it’s not a good decision to get them as a family dog if you have toddlers at home. They are best accompanied by older kids that can respect their space. Pitbull vs. Rottweiler? It’s up to your preference.
Rottweilers, on the other hand, are known to be vicious breeds. They are popular as a guard dog and will be ready to fight in the face of imminent danger. Rottweilers are loyal and cuddly if trained to be. Still, as a herding dog, they can nip and chase moving objects out of the blue.
But if Rotties are domesticated and trained intensively, they will be playful and friendly to their family. Still, they will retain their attentive and doubtful instincts toward strangers. They can be great with kids, but Rotts simply don’t know how large they are which will cause them to knock off babies and toddlers out of excitement.
For a quick comparison of the Pitbull and Rottweiler breeds, here’s an informative video from talkPets:
Pitbulls can be stubborn doggos so make sure that you train them in a calm but firm manner. They also have a short attention span (like a mischievous toddler) so it’s best to train them in short drills and have some treats ready to keep them engaged. They tend to test the confidence of their owner by imposing their dominance. Make sure that you will be the leader of the pack and not the other way around.
If you’re thinking of getting a Pitbull as a family and guard dog, get a puppy. This way, you can socialize them early so they can accept kids like welcomed guests. Regardless if you choose a Rottweiler or Pitbull, should also introduce them to other people.
Rottweilers can be hard-headed too. They will show their dominance and fierce side which overwhelms newbie and inexperienced owners. What you need here is firmness and consistency. Never shout or your Rottweiler will start to go bonkers. You shouldn’t relax the rules or else, they will go all the way without your permission.
Pitbull vs. Rottweiler: What’s good and bad about ‘em
The good thing about Pitbulls is you can train them to be friendly and aggressive enough to deter intruders. Their appearance is also intimidating which makes them excellent guard dogs. However, you have to research carefully about their bloodline if you want to get a stable-tempered dog. Pitbulls tend to be rowdy and aggressive toward other animals and people if not socialized well.
Pitbulls require a confident owner who can suppress their stubbornness and imposing nature. Aside from that, they can be darlings too with proper training and if their bloodline doesn’t come from fighting dogs. Rottweiler vs. Pitbull, you be the judge.
On the other hand, what’s good about Rottweilers is that they are usually calm. They also bear the intimidating look of most hunting and herding hounds which can deter burglars. Take note that Rottweilers are one of the smartest dog breeds. You have to be confident and ready to take on the challenge of training them to channel their intelligence into something good.
And just like Pitbulls, they need proper socialization regardless if they are intended to be guard dogs. They also get bored and aggressive if left for long hours and deprived of physical and mental stimulation.
Take note these two breeds may raise legal liabilities like future breed ban, insurance issues, and potential lawsuits if not trained well.
The perfect family and protection dog
Pitbull vs. Rottweiler? I can say that both can be excellent family dogs. But if you’re looking for a doggo that can be both friendly to your kids and vigilant to strangers, Rottweilers are the best. They have a higher guarding potential, amazing obedience level, better temperament with children, and more affectionate toward their owners.
Based on our analysis, Rottweilers and Ptibulls have similar physical and mental needs. However, you should be careful with Rottweilers since they are prone to obesity due to haphazard feeding.
For more information about the comparison of these two breeds, you can check the chart here.
Rottweiler or Pitbull? In the end, the choice is in your hands. These two dogs are versatile, but if you want smart one, you’ll never go wrong with a Rottweiler.